Which Natural Alternatives to Shaving Cream are Irritation-Free?

Whether searching for a perfect solution to avoid razor burn and irritation or looking for a gift for a loved one, natural alternatives to shaving cream are there to save the day. This is why I made a list of the best eco-friendly, cruelty-free shaving products.

One natural shaving cream I found to be great is Taylor of Old Bond Street sandalwood cream that will make shaving smooth, clean and refreshing.

natural alternatives to shaving cream

* We put a lot of effort into researching eco-friendly products for our readers. We want to be clear that as an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Benefits of natural alternatives to shaving cream

If shaving is something you do every day, you probably don’t want to even think about the number of chemicals you put on your skin and then rinse down the drain. Often, natural alternatives to shaving cream are made and sold by people who struggled with the exact same problem as other shavers. So, what makes them stand out from the regular shaving products?

  • Good for sensitive skin: they do not contain parabens, phthalates, SLS and other chemicals;
  • Fight razor burn: the smooth texture forms a protective barrier on the skin;
  • Clean, refreshing result: the natural formula leaves the skin healthy and moisturized;
  • No allergies: the natural ingredients are less likely to cause adverse reactions;
  • Natural glow: organic components naturally improve the condition of the skin;
  • Eco-friendly: plant-based ingredients are more sustainable for the planet;
  • Zero-waste: many creams come in a recyclable package;
  • Cruelty-free: responsible producers never test their products on animals.

Besides, most natural shaving creams can be applied and used in the same way as traditional ones, so there is no need for a major shift in habits to become more eco-friendly.

5 natural alternatives to shaving cream

These eco-friendly, organic products improve both the skin and the planet.

1. Burt’s Bees Natural Skin Care for Men Shave Cream

  • 6 oz
  • 99% natural
  • Cruelty-free
  • Recyclable package
  • All skin types, sensitive
  • Hand application

Burt’s Bees shave cream for men is designed for all skin types and it is made from 99% natural ingredients. Calendula extract makes it nicely soothing for the skin, and the plant-sourced ingredients give the skin an extra boost of natural glow. This cream does not contain beeswax, so it might be suitable for vegans, even though it does not have the appropriate stamp. Still, it is a good idea to check the ingredients to be sure.

Reviews

While some buyers were disappointed that this natural alternative to shaving cream does not lather and foam, others explained that this actually helps against irritation and makes a shave cleaner. Some reported that since switching to use this organic shaving cream they had less ingrown hair and stopped having allergic reactions. Reviewers also recommended it as an easy travel alternative to traditional brush and foam shaving. However, some found the smell too strong. More reviews

2. Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Cream Bowl

  • 5.7 oz
  • Plant-based
  • Cruelty-free
  • Vegan
  • Recyclable package
  • All skin types
  • Brush application

This Taylor of Old Bond Street classic comes in a variety of scents, but the musky sandalwood is a timeless staple. This shaving cream creates a rich lather and is best applied with a brush. The seller does not specify how natural this cream is but says that all of its products are plant-derived, contain no animal ingredients and are cruelty-free.

Reviews

Buyers say that this shaving cream whips into a satisfyingly thick lather makes shaving smooth and clean, and leaves the skin feeling moisturized and soft. On the other hand, washing it off can be somewhat difficult. Shavers also love the sandalwood smell, but some found it too overpowering. But many reviewers who spent a lot of time and effort on finding the perfect natural alternative to shaving cream concluded that this one gives the best shaving experience for the money. More reviews

3. Pacific Shaving Company Natural Shaving Cream

  • 3.4 oz
  • Plant-based, organic
  • Cruelty-free
  • Vegan
  • All skin types, sensitive
  • Hand application

Pacific Shaving Company makes its shaving creams from all-natural, plant-derived ingredients. The key components are aloe and shea butter, which soothe and moisturize the skin, leaving it hydrated and smooth after shaving. This natural alternative to shaving cream comes in travel-sized tubs so it is easy to take on a plane and enjoy a clean shave even away from home. And thanks to the concentrated formula, the tub will last for months despite its small size.

Reviews

This shaving cream gets a lot of positive reviewers from long-time shavers who have tried many different products in a search for a perfect shaving experience. They like the subtle scent, the thick leather, the clean result, and the smooth, irritation-free skin. Customers say that when using this cream there is no razor burn, and it performs well even for unusually thick hair and delicate skin. However, many people had problems with the tube that easily broke from the sealed top. Some also said that it dries out too fast. More reviews

4. Natural Shave Cream by Nurture My Body

  • 4 oz
  • Plant-based, certified organic
  • Cruelty-free
  • Vegan
  • All skin types, sensitive
  • Hand application

This Nurture My Body product is one of the no-lather natural alternatives to shaving cream and it should be applied to the face in a thin layer without using a brush. It uses only plant-derived ingredients to create a natural, smooth and effortless shaving experience. The organic components gently protect the skin from irritation and razor burn, while nourishing and moisturizing it at the same time. This shaving cream is particularly great for sensitive skin since it has the lowest possible EWG toxicity rating.

Reviews

Reviewers seemed to have divided opinions about this product. Being a natural alternative to shaving cream, it created a different shaving experience which some did not appreciate. The lack of foam and application by hand felt dissatisfying to some. Others, on the other hand, enjoyed the smooth and easy shave free of irritation. It is worth noting that this cream is not suitable for use with electric razors as it will clog them. More reviews

5. Brickell Men’s Smooth Brushless Shave Cream for Men

  • 5 oz
  • 99% natural, 72% organic
  • Cruelty-free
  • Vegan
  • All skin types, sensitive
  • Hand application

Brickell Men’s shave cream is designed to prevent cuts and razor burn and keep all skin types moisturized. It works especially well for sensitive, irritation-prone skin. The rich non-lathering shave cream is made from natural and certified ingredients that nourish and hydrate the face, protecting it during shaving and leaving it fresh and clean throughout the day. As a bonus point for green consumers, all of the company’s products are vegan and cruelty-free and do not contain parabens, phthalates, and other chemicals.

Reviews

While most people enjoyed the smooth, silky texture of this cream, others reported that the contents of the jar were uneven and it was impossible to mix them. The shaving experience was also different, as several reviewers felt that the cream does not create any protection for the skin. Still, many people with very sensitive skin commended this cream for the most effortless shaving experience they ever had. More reviews

The best natural alternative to shaving cream

It can take years to find your perfect shaving product, and even the best cream might just not work for you. Still, when choosing among all the natural alternatives to shaving cream, there are a few things that are worth checking. It is good to know how organic the product is, what skin type is it designed for and how it should be applied.

natural alternatives to shaving cream

Taylor of Old Bond Street sandalwood shaving cream seems like an excellent option on all counts. It is vegan, cruelty-free and comes in a recyclable bowl. I think it is a great addition to an eco-friendly bathroom. Especially when switching from traditional shaving cream applied with a brush. Unlike many natural alternatives to shaving cream, this product lathers into a rich foam and is applied in a similar way.

And for those willing to experiment, it is also easy to make a natural DYI shaving cream at home. Most recipes are based on coconut or olive oil that are known for their moisturizing and nourishing properties. Note that this might not work for all skin types as the oil might clog pores.